Episode 034: “Please Mister Postman”

What happens when the Beatles take a Motown classic and make it their own? Please Mr. Postman was already a #1 hit for the Marvelettes, but John Lennon’s urgent, near-desperate vocal delivery transforms it into something raw and electrifying. In this episode, Peter and Kenyon explore how the Beatles' version differs from the original, from its tighter rhythm section to its heightened emotional intensity. The hosts discuss why this was the final girl-group cover the Beatles ever recorded and how their choice to include it reflected their deep admiration for American R&B. They also examine the recording session, highlighting the Beatles' decision to rework their live arrangement mid-session to better match the Marvelettes’ dynamic intro. Was this just a well-executed cover or something more? Join Peter and Kenyon as they break down Please Mister Postman and uncover why the Beatles’ version remains a fan favorite.

Listen to full episode :